[Last updated: 22 March 2022]

Johan Friederich Stembel (Great-grandfather)

Frederick Stembel (Grandfather)

John Stembel (Father)

Joseph V. S. Stembel

JOSEPH VAN SWEARINGEN STEMBEL (1828-1920)

Mary and Joseph Stembel

Joseph was born in Middletown, Maryland, on July 28, 1828. He was the youngest of John and Elenor's 12 children (only six of whom survived to adulthood). Joseph was named after his mother's father, General Joseph Van Swearingen⁽¹⁾ (Van was his middle name rather than part of his surname). When Joseph was about 3 years old his family moved to Ohio, eventually settling on a farm southwest of West Liberty in Champaign County. Growing up, he attended private subscription schools (free public education did not yet exist).⁽²⁾

When Joseph was 22, he married Mary Magdalena Ziegler. Mary was born in Perry County, Ohio, the eldest of eight children. Her parents moved to Champaign County when she was 2 years old.⁽³⁾ The Ziegler farm was located very close to the Stembel's farm. It seems likely the two families were closely acquainted and that Joseph and Mary knew each other since childhood. After their marriage, Joseph bought a piece of land, 128 acres, just west of his father's farm.⁽⁴⁾ It was across the road from his wife's family farm and the house where she grew up. Joseph built a house and farmed the land. They lived there for the rest of their entire adult life.

A 1874 land ownership map shows the location of Joseph's farm. His father's farm, where Joseph grew up, was located to the east, where his siblings still owned their share of their parent's farm. The map also shows the location of the family's church, Wesley Chapel M. E. Church, which is where Joseph and Mary were eventually buried.

Joseph and Mary had eight children, all of whom reached adulthood and married. Mary was raised as a Lutheran, but she joined the nearby Wesley Chapel Church, where the Stembels worshiped, in 1855. All eight of her children attended the church as well. Joseph, however, did not join the church until 1911. This was Mary's final wish as she lay on her deathbed.⁽⁵⁾ This illustrates Joseph's great affection for his wife of 60 years.

In 1901, Joseph and Mary celebrated their 50^th wedding anniversary. All eight of their children attended, as well as most, if not all, of their grandchildren. A family portrait taken that day included 53 family members! Joseph, though seated, appears to be a tall, trim man with full dark hair (at the age of 73) with a white beard 7 or 8 inches long. He has a granddaughter on his lap (see the photo on the home page).

50^th Wedding Anniversary (1901). Standing L-R: Malissa, George, John, Mary, Catherine, Albert, William, Addie; Seated: Joseph, Mary.

In 1910 Mary and Joseph again celebrated their wedding anniversary with a huge family reunion. This was their 59^th, and last, anniversary together. Joseph and Mary were both 82 years old. Seven of their eight children attended (their oldest, Malissa, had passed away eight years before). A newspaper account of that gathering reported there were 107 guests in attendance. Besides their seven children, there were 38 grandchildren, and 20 great-grandchildren.⁽⁶⁾ Mary died six months later.

59^th Wedding Anniversary (1910). Standing L-R: Mary, Albert, Catherine, William, Addie; Seated: George, (empty chair for Malissa-deceased), Mary, Joseph, John.

Joseph lived nine more years. During this time two more of his children died, George Oren and Albert. Joseph died in February 1920. He was 91 years old. Both Mary and Joseph are buried in the cemetery at Wesley Chapel. At the time of his death, Joseph was the oldest original settler in Champaign County.⁽⁷⁾

Wesley Chapel Church and cemetery, Wesley Chapel Road, southwest of West Liberty, Ohio.

Joseph and Mary Stembel's tombstone in Wesley Chapel Church's cemetery.

Joseph and Mary Stembel's eight children:

A. Malissa Stembel Emery. (1852-1902). Malissa was born June 7, 1852, near West Liberty. Ohio. Much of what I know about Malissa comes from the 1880 and 1900 census. Malissa married John W. Emery on New Years Day, 1874. John was 24, Malissa 22. They had nine children between the years 1875 and 1892. The first eight were girls; the ninth was a boy.

At the time of the 1880 census they lived on a farm in Harrison Township, Champaign County. Also living with them at the time was a 20 year old servant girl (Nancy Dewey), a 26 year old hired hand (John Egnar from New York) and the hired hand's mother.

In 1900 they still lived on a farm in Harrison Township. They had a hired hand, 20 year old Samuel Jenkins.

John died in 1901 at the age of 50. Malissa died a year later, leaving their children, aged 9, 11, 13, 16, and 18, orphaned. Both are buried in West Liberty's Fairview Cemetery.

John and Malissa Emery's children:

1. Viola A. Emery Yoder.(1874-1905) Viola was known as "Ola". She was born December 26, 1874. She married Chris Yoder about 1893. Five children are shown in the 1910 census: Bertha, Gladys, Wilson, Catherine, and Edgar. The 1910 census presents us with a bit of a mystery. There is only one Chris Yoder in the 1910 census in Logan or Champaign County, and that is a Christionie Yoder (I believe Chris's full name was Christian E.). According to the census, this man's wife's name was Vera, not Viola, and she was 41 years old (Viola would have been 35 in 1910). Given the fact that people almost never overstate their age in the census, I believe Viola died sometime before the 1910 census, and that Chris remarried. This is reinforced by the ages of Chris's children: 16, 12, 9, 2, and 1. Note the seven year gap between the nine year old and the two year old. In fact, Viola did die before the 1910 census. She is buried in the Bellefontaine City Cemetery where her tombstone shows she died in 1905. She was just 30 years old.
2. Mary Catherine Emery Wass.(1877-1940). Mary was born April 6, 1877. I'm told Mary went by the name "Mame." About 1894 she married John Wass. John was an electrician. They had three children: Lewis (known as "Emery"), Donald, and Mary. In 1900 they were living in Urbana, Ohio. In 1910 they were living in Owensboro, Kentucky, and in 1920 they were living in Greencastle, Indiana. Mary died May 24, 1940, and in buried in Plymouth, Indiana, in their Oak Hill Cemetery.
3. Josephine Elvina Emery Butcher.(1879-1965) "Josie" was born June 22, 1879. She married Charles A. Butcher in November 1902. They had eight known children though it appears some died in childhood: Marion (male), a male baby (unnamed), Harold, Paul, Joseph, Geneva, Robert, and Theodore. In 1930 they were living in Springfield, Ohio. Charles died in Dayton, Ohio, on May 8, 1949. Josie died on September 14, 1965, also in Dayton. Charles and Josephine are both buried in Newson Cemetery, Christiansburg (Champaign County), Ohio.
4. Carrie Leonard Emery Kaufman.(1881- ). Carrie was born September 8, 1881. On May 22, 1906, she married Earl S. Kaufman who was three years older than her. Soon after their marriage they moved to Colorado. They were living in Denver at the time of the 1910 census. By 1920 they were back in Ohio, where Earl was manager of a lumber yard in the town of Uniopolis (Auglaze County). They had four children according to census records: Earl, Maxine, Donna, and Ned. They lived in Uniopolis for most of their adult lives. I have no record of their deaths.
5. Grace Malissa Emery Hanger.(1883-1974) Grace was born October 9, 1883, in Champaign County. Sometime around 1903 she married Arthur Garfield Hanger. In 1910 they were living on a farm in Champaign County. That same year they attended Joseph and Mary's 59^th anniversary and family reunion. Census records show three known children: Henry, Bernice, and William. They were still farming in Champaign County according to the census records, but by 1930 they had moved to California, and residing in Redondo Beach, where Arthur worked as a gardiner for a country club. Arthur died July 18, 1966, in Los Angeles. Grace remained in California. She died March 12, 1974, in San Pedro.
6. Ida Belle Emery Smucker.(1885-1925) My information about Ida and her family was provided by her great-granddaughter, Kristin Hall Sliwicki. Ida was born October 11, 1885. When she was 15 her father died. A year later her mother died. Ida, and her younger brother, Harry, were taken in by Lydia and David Smucker who lived in West Liberty, Ohio. The Smuckers had a son, John Oliver who was four years older than Ida. In 1905, John (who went by his initials, "J.O.") and Ida married. After the wedding they took up residence in nearby Bellefontaine, Ohio. According to Kristin, J.O. owned a music store and their home was always filled with music. He was also an undertaker, like his father, according to the 1910 and 1920 censuses. In 1910 Ida and J.O. attended her grandparent's (Mary and Joseph Stembel) 59^th anniversary celebration and family reunion. Ida and J.O. had two children: David Emery (born 1907) and John Kirby (born 1909). David was Kristin's grandfather. He earned a degree in civil engineering at Ohio State University and went on to become Executive Vice-President of Operations for the Pennsylvania Railroad.


Ida died of cancer on October 26, 1925, just days after her 40^th birthday. She is buried in the Bellefontaine City Cemetery. J.O. remarried five years later.
7. Eva Stembel Emery Funderburg.(1888-1947) Eva was born August 3, 1888, in Champaign County. When she was 12 her father died. A year later her mother died. At the age of 13 she was orphaned. She may have been taken in by her older sister, Josephine, and her husband. I suspect this because in the 1910 census Eva was living in Springfield, Ohio, where she was a 21 year-old, single, telephone operator. Springfield is located in the same county that Josephine's family was living in. Three years later Eva married Coral V. Funderburg. Coral had been married before and had two children by that marriage. Soon after they married, Eva and Coral moved to Michigan where they had a daughter, Constance. By 1920, they had moved back to Greene County, where Coral had been born. Coral was an electrician. Soon after the 1920 census, they moved to San Bernardino, California, where Coral's skill as an electrician were in demand. Eva died June 23, 1947, at the age of 58. Coral died January 9, 1973. He was 84.


In 2009 I received an email from a grandchild (or step-grandchild) of Eva's who shared a few memories of her "Grandma Eva": "Grandma Eva was Aunt Connie's mother ["Connie" was Constance Funderburg]. She was a wonderful grandma. I used to stay with her over weekends sometimes. One time she took me to Thrifty Drug Store for lunch. We had salads, which I have always remembered, a half of head of really large iceberg lettuce with dressing. I didn't think I'd ever be able to eat it all. She also made the best deviled eggs. She used dry mustard in them with some vinegar along with the mayonaise etc. She gave me a lot of sheet music and I sang some of her favorite songs at her funeral. She was really up in the Eas[t]ern Star [the Order of the Eastern Star is a Freemason organisation open to men and women. It was quite popular in the late 19th and early to middle 20th century]."
8. Harriet Ammanon Emery Werner.(1890- ) Harriet was born June 2, 1890. She was known as "Hattie" and "Amme". At the age of 11 her mother died (her father had died the year before) leaving her orphaned. It appears that she went to live with her sister, Grace, and her husband Arthur Hanger, on their farm in Harrison Township, Champaign County, Ohio, for that's where she was living in the 1910 census. She was an Army nurse in WW I. She was relieved from duty on June 12, 1919. According to a relative, she married Gustav Werner, a German brewer. Later in life she lived in Melbourne, Florida. She was described by a relative who visited her often as "Spunky and full of life."
9. Harry Lewis Emery.(1892-1974). Harry was born on July 23, 1892. When he was nine his mother died. This came a year after a year his father died. So at the age of nine he was an orphan. He and his sister Ida were taken in by Lydia and David Smucker who lived in West Liberty, Ohio. Evidently, after his sister married in 1905, he went to live with the newly-weds, for in the 1910 census Harry was living with his sister Ida and her husband. He was attending school. A few years later Harry married Mary Detrick. According to census records Harry and Mary had just one child, John D. ("Jack"). They lived at various times in Bellefontaine, Dayton, San Antonio, and Los Angeles. Harry died December 28, 1974, in Los Angeles, California. Mary died a year later, also in Los Angeles. Both are buried in Fairview Cemetery, West Liberty, Ohio.

B. George Oren Stembel (1853-1914). George is the subject of a later chapter.

C. John Virgil Stembel (1855-1937). Joseph and Mary's third child, John, was born on July 23, 1855, near West Liberty, Ohio. He was educated in the public schools of Champaign County.⁽⁸⁾ On June 29, 1879, he married Emma Barger. John was almost 24, Emma was 20. They had seven children, two of whom died young.

In the 1900 census, John and Emma were living in Union Township, Champaign County, where John was a Farm Laborer. Three of their children were living with them. In the 1910 census, John, Emma, and their youngest son Willie, were living with John's parents. His father, Joseph, was 81 and had turned the farm over to John.

While it appears John and Emma lived in Champaign County their entire life, a birth announcement in the 1898 Louisville Courier-Journal newspaper announced the birth of a child, gender unspecified, to a John and Emma Stemble, living at 1927 Logan Street. No other known Stembel family fits this birth announcement even though they had never been recorded living anywhere but in Champaign County. Also, a son born just a year earlier was born in Champaign County (though we don't have proof of that fact). Why John and Emma would have been in Louisville for this birth is a mystery. Adding to this mystery is the fact that in the 1900 census, Emma reported she had given birth to 6, not 7, children, 5 of which were still living.

John was a member of the Wesley Chapel Episcopal Methodist Church and the Masonic Lodge.⁽⁹⁾ He died at the age of 76 on March 12, 1937; Emma died 5 months later.

John and Emma Stembel's seven children:

1. Effie May Stembel.(1879-1880) Effie May was born in October 1879, but died just months later on March 31, 1880. We don't have a record of her birth, but we know what month she was born because her death was recorded in the 1880 Census Mortality Schedule which recorded her age at death (5 months old). She died of whooping cough. She is buried in the Concord Cemetery, St. Paris, Champaign County, Ohio.
2. Addie Bessie Stembel Bishop.(1881-1970) Addie was born 13 March 1881. In 1900 she married Frank Bishop, who was about 15 years older than she (it may have been Frank's second marriage). Frank was a farmer. They lived in Champaign County all their life. They had no children. According to the newspaper account, Addie and Frank attended Mary and Joseph's 59^th wedding anniversary in 1910.
3. Maud L. Stembel Sigenthaler.(1884-1955) Maudie was born September 14, 1884. In October 1901 she married Gottlieb Seigenthaler. Gottlieb was born in Switzerland in 1792. He was 12 years older than Maudie. They had at least six children: Wilber, Gilbert, Marguerette, Minnie, Ruth, and Leona. All six married. Maudie and Gottlieb lived in Springhills, Ohio. In 1910 Maud and Gottlieb attended Mary and Joseph's wedding anniversary in 1910. Gottlieb died in 1949 and is buried in the Springhill Cemetery. Maud died in 1955 and is buried in King's Creek Cemetery (both are in Champaign County).
4. Mattie Stembel Roberts.(1886-1938) Mattie was born in January 1886. On October 1, 1903, she married Clarence Roberts in the Grace Methodist Church, in Urbana, Ohio.⁽¹⁰⁾ Mattie was 17. Clarence was 21. They had at least two children, Dorothy and Helen. Both lived to adulthood and married. Sometime before 1920, Mattie and Clarence moved the family to Springfield, Ohio. Mattie died in 1938. I have no record of Clarence's death.
5. James H. Stembel.(1888-1915) James was born August 1888. In the 1910 census, James was working as a farm laborer. Soon after the census he married Ethel Journell. They had one child, Donald, who was born in 1913. James died soon after, on November 7, 1915.⁽¹¹⁾ In 1929, Ethel re-married, to William Hagenbaugh. In 1946, Donald married and had three known children. Ethel died in 1966.
6. William Edward Stembel.(1897-1928). William was born in March of 1896. On December 23, 1916, he married Jessie Leota Mason . The wedding took place in the First Methodist Church in Urbana. They had one known child, a son, Edwin. Sadly, William died in 1928 at the age of 32. Jessie remarried a few years later. Their son, Edwin, married and had at least one child.
7. [unknown] Stembel.(1898- ) We only know of this child, name and gender unknown, because of a birth announcement published in the September 24, 1898, edition of the Louisville Courier-Journal newspaper. The child was born to a John and Emma Stemble. It could only be our John Stembel. The child did not appear in the 1900 census, so we assume it died before the census was taken. However, in the 1900 census, Emma indicated she had given birth to six children, five of which were still living, which does cast some doubt on this being their child.

D. Mary Louize Stembel Kirkwood. (1857-1951). Mary was born March 2, 1857, near West Liberty, Ohio. In September of 1881 she married Robert Kirkwood, son of David and Mary Kirkwood. Robert was 31 years old, seven years older than Mary. He was a school teacher.

At the time of the 1900 census, Mary and Robert were living on West Beard Street in West Liberty, Ohio. In 1910 they attended Mary and Joseph's 59^th anniversary. According to the newspaper account, they were now living in Urbana, Ohio.

Robert died in 1924, at the age of 74. Mary lived 27 more years. Sometime after her husband's death she moved to Columbus, Ohio, where she was living at the time of the 1930 census. She died in 1951 at the age of 94.

Mary and Robert Kirkwood's children:

1. Ralph Van Swearingen Kirkwood.(1882-1930) Ralph was born in June of 1882. He married Laura Botcher sometime around 1907. He was an electrician. They had at least one child, Dorothy, born in 1909. By 1910 they had moved to Leavenworth, Kansas. The 1920 census recorded them in Jeffersonville, Indiana. Ralph died in 1930, at the age of 47 in Washington, DC.
2. Laura Blanche Kirkwood Bishop.(1883-1962) Laura was born in October of 1883. She married William Irvin Bishop sometime around 1907. In 1910 they were living in Mansfield, Ohio. They had at least one child, Lucille, born in 1908. Lucille married John Sitterley and had two children. Laura and William moved to Columbus sometime before the 1920 census. Laura died in 1962. William died three years later.

E. Catherine Eleanor Stembel Duff. (1861-1940). Catherine was born March 9, 1861, near West Liberty, Ohio. She was known as "Ella." Catherine married John K. Duff on December 20, 1885. She was 24. I believe John was three years older than she. Ella and John attended Joseph and Mary's 59^th wedding anniversary. The newspaper article indicated they were living in Rushylvania (Logan County), Ohio, at the time. Ella and John had three children, and lived in Logan County, Ohio, their whole lives.

In early censuses, her parents spelled her name with a C, Catherine. It appears that later in life she preferred to spell it with a K, Katherine.

John died April 22, 1936; Catherine lived four more years. She passed away on October 9, 1940, at the age of 79.

Catherine and John Duff's three children:

1. Joseph L. Duff.(1886-1965) Joseph was born in November of 1886. In 1910 he attended his grandparent's 59^th wedding anniversary. He was living at Belle Center, Ohio (Logan County) at the time. According to my records, Joseph married Edna Flickenger soon after 1910. They had 5 children and lived in Logan County most of their lives. Joseph was a mail carrier.


Edna died in 1946. Joseph died in 1965. Both are buried in Fairview Cemetery, Belle Center, Ohio.
2. Forest Duff.(1889-1935) Forest was born in May of 1889. He also attended his grandparent's wedding anniversary. The newspaper reports he was living in Springfield, Ohio. Soon after the 1910 census he married Ella Marie Brown, and they had at least six children. Forest was a farmer, and later worked for the railroad. It appears they lived in Logan County most of their lives. Forest died in 1935 and is buried in Fairview Cemetery, West Liberty, Ohio. Ella remarried.
3. Leona Duff Miller.(1894-1955) Leona was born in April of 1894. She was just 16 at the time of her grandparents wedding anniversary, where according to the newspaper, she gave a recitation. Sometime before the 1930 census she married Robert E. Miller. He was about 18 years older than Leona and this may have been his second marriage. According to my information, they had no children. They lived most of their lives in Logan County. Leona died in 1955. Robert died a year later. Both are buried In Huntsville Cemetery, Huntsville, Ohio.

F. Albert Frederick Stemble⁽¹²⁾. (1864-1916). Albert Frederick was born January 16, 1864, near West Liberty, Ohio. He was the sixth child born to Joseph and Mary Stembel. Little is known about his childhood. I assume he worked on his father's farm a few miles southwest of West Liberty, and attended school (the 1880 census says he attened school the previous year).

At the age of 18, Albert traveled to Missouri in 1882 with his cousins John and Lafe (Marcellus Lafayette) Stembel (see chapter on Oliver Stembel). John was 30 and Lafe was 26. It appears that Albert's stay in Missouri was brief, since a year later he was back home in Ohio. There he married Nettie Pine in 1883. He may have been contemplating a move to Missouri after his marriage, but he evidently felt conditions were better in Ohio, for that's where he lived the rest of his life.

Albert and Nettie had three children between 1884 and 1888. Sadly, Nettie died in 1892; she was only 29 years old. Albert, a widower at age 28, remarried three years later. His new wife was 21-year-old Olive Frey, known as "Ollie." Albert and Ollie had three more children. The last was born in 1901.

Albert demonstrated his independent spirit by legally changing his surname. Tired of having his name misspelled, Albert declared the 'Stembel' spelling to be old-fashioned (in his words) and legally changed the spelling to 'Stemble.' Since then, Albert's descendants have spelled their last name Stemble.

In the 1910 census, Albert's occupation was recorded as 'Farm Manager.' His farm was located in Harrison Township, Champaign County, Ohio.

Albert died in 1916 at the age of 52. Ollie lived 37 more years. In 1930 she was living with her daughter's family, Marie (Pearl) and Ralph Fretz. Ollie passed away in 1953. Albert and both of his wives are buried in Oak Dale Cemetery in Urbana, Ohio. Nettie was initially buried somewhere else but her remains were reburied in Oak Dale to be with Albert after his death. This move must have met with the approval of Albert's second wife, Ollie.

Albert Stemble's six children (with two wives):